Stamford electors choose ‘None of the Above’

Here is the text of a letter I sent to Stamford Mercury this week concerning the recent low turnout in the two Stamford by-elections in St John’s Ward (20.8%) and St George’s Ward (17.2%) …

“Dear Editor

Congratulations to Rachael Cooke and David Taylor on winning the Stamford by-elections last week. I genuinely hope they make a positive difference to the quality of representation at South Kesteven District Council.

Sadly, their mandate has already been undermined by most people in Stamford. Despite the recent hyperbole about taking back control and the importance of a centenary of women’s suffrage, fewer than twenty percent of eligible voters turned out last week and fewer than one in ten residents expressed a preference for either of the aforementioned candidates.

I can understand why people are disillusioned with the current archaic electoral system.  Due to absence of proportional representation, most people do not get the person or party we voted for at either local or national level. At last year’s Lincolnshire County elections the Conservatives gained 54 percent of the vote but collected over 80 per cent of the seats. This situation cannot be accurately described as representative democracy.

Another reason for public disengagement is the mostly unfair portrayal of politicians by the media as being self-interested, corrupt and disconnected. Anyone who witnesses the passion, patience and attention to detail displayed by Councillors at almost any meeting will understand local politics is not about fame or fortune.

Finally, people don’t vote because they don’t think it makes any difference. Recent high profile planning cases such as Kettering Road where inspectors have over-ruled the decisions of councillors do cause one to wonder but there are plenty of sensible planning decisions which are upheld on appeal and consequently do not attract attention in the press. Furthermore, even a lowly backbench Independent like me can influence decision making and occasionally put forward and win an argument for change.

Come on, Stamford! If you are unhappy with the hegemony of the Lincolnshire Tories then get involved. Turn up to the meetings, write to your Councillors, even stand for election if you like, but most importantly make sure you vote. Every Councillor does make a difference for better or for worse and voter apathy can cost lives.

Yours faithfully,

Cllr Ashley Baxter (Ind)
Market & West Deeping Ward”

SK Today – Response

The Communications Team at SK have sent a reply to my e-mail. They have requested I publish it here which I am more than happy to do.

The response spends a lot of time defending the stories about Grantham and argues that perhaps they are relevant to residents of the Deepings. If that’s the case, I would argue that the main reason they are relevant is that Deepings residents help to pay for Grantham activities in one way or another. That would be fine if the Deepings was not ignored… but it is!

I am not really concerned about the plethora of stories about Grantham but rather the dearth of stories about the rest of the District and particularly the Deepings. Two of the reasons for the lack of stories from the deep south are: a) there isn’t much SKDC activity in the Deepings; and b) even if there was, many officers aren’t aware of what’s happening as they rarely find reason to venture out of Grantham.

Last year, if I am not mistaken, the Council published only three press releases specifically about the Deepings. All of them concerned the Literary Festival which took place last April (There may have been others about the Local Plan consultation and the Big Clean project in the Deepings but those related to District-wide projects).

I have personally tried to counteract this problem by sending e-mails (with various shades of grumpiness), suggesting stories for inclusion. These include the duck race, the carnival, the leisure centre, Jubilee Park and the Deepings Raft Race. The latter is one of the biggest and best volunteer events in the region. After speaking to some of the raft race committee I asked South Kesteven if they could support the event. After long exchange of e-mails SKDC offered to supply some bin bags and litter-pickers..  but only if they could be collected from Grantham! That story perhaps deserves a little more context but the gist reinforces my repeated argument that, for many (not all) officers at Grantham, the Deepings is out-of-sight and out-of-mind.

I have also proposed, since 2015, that the Council occasionally hold some of its committee meetings elsewhere than Grantham. In response to a motion I submitted to Full Council on 23rd November last year, the following was agreed:

“This Council encourages its Committee Chairmen to consider the venue for holding committee meetings to ensure that at least one formal meeting (e.g. an OSC meeting) is held in each of the 3 smaller towns (Stamford, Bourne and Market Deeping) during each calendar year.”

Nearly six months on and, finally, the Council is planning for a scheduled meeting of the Cabinet to take place outside Grantham – at Bourne Corn Exchange to be precise on Thursday 12th April at 2pm. I hope someone takes a photograph!

 

SK Today – Spring 2018

Here is the text of an e-mail I have just sent to the South Kesteven’s Communications Team regarding the recent edition of SK Today

“Dear [name redacted],

Today I received a bundle of marketing leaflets dropped through my letterbox and I was busily taking them straight to my recycling bin (provided by SKDC) when I noticed the Spring edition of SK Today was buried among them. Obviously I dropped everything and sat down for a good read.

I suspect a vast number of people in Market Deeping and West Deeping will be delighted with the two-page spread about Wyndham Park (in Grantham) and the two-page spread about the Gravity Fields festival planned for later this year in Grantham. I do hope you will find space for an update on these two stories later in the year!

And then there’s news of Grantham’s Southern Relief Road; and Grantham’s new cinema operator; and Grantham’s struggling hospital; and everything that’s happening at the Meres Centre in Grantham.

I’m particularly interested in the Christchurch Grantham Arts Break Out event. It appears to be a community event with no link to the Council. I’m all for this sort of story in SK Today although slightly bewildered as I have been previously been told by Cllr Goral that “…we don’t use council resource to promote non council events in Grantham, Bourne or Stamford, we don’t promote non council events in The Deepings.”  Can you explain the link between the Council and the ‘Arts Break Out’ as the weblink provided for more information is very short on detail.

The two-page spread on the RAF would be more interesting if it mentioned either of the two war-time airfields in the Deepings. https://www.stamfordmercury.co.uk/news/remembering-when-frognall-buzzed-with-war-planes-1-6345786

A fascinating column about markets although no mention of Market Deeping’s existing market or the plans for a Saturday market in the town.

My personal highlight of this edition though, is at the bottom of page 7 where I have found what I think is the single solitary mention of Market Deeping. It’s good to know we’re not completely forgotten even if we have to share our sentence with Stamford, Grantham and Horbling!

Apologies if I sound narky but we have been having this conversation for well over a year now with precious little evidence of progress.

Kind regards,

Cllr Ashley Baxter

Market & West Deeping

SKDC”

***Update: The Communications team has replied and I have published their response here***

An introduction to Party Politics at SKDC

One often hears the old fallacy that “all politicians are the same”. This is simply not the case and the colourful characters at South Kesteven Council prove the point. Furthermore, some people also have the mistaken impression that an Independent Councillor is isolated and works alone. The groups at SKDC outlined below illustrate how Independents are perfectly capable of organising themselves and working together for the common good as much, if not more than, the old-fashioned Political Parties.rosettes

The following list of party groups is intended as an overview of the current political structure of South Kesteven District Council (as of 20th March 2018).

Independent Group – 6 Members
Seven people were elected as Independent in 2015, including one who stood as a Lincolnshire Independent. Six of us joined forces to form the Independent Group while the seventh chose to remain unaligned (Independent of the Independents)

The Group includes a very diverse range of backgrounds and opinions. Some members of the group have a regular pre-meeting before full Council to discuss the agenda but it there is no whip or block vote and members of the group often take different sides in a debate. The main glue holding the group together is the fact that by declaring ourselves a political group we become the second largest group on the council and therefore ‘the opposition’. Places on committees are allocated in accordance with the size of the various groups in order to acheived a ‘political balance’ and as second largest group we earn at least one seat on every committee. We all agree that having access to committees is far  better than working in isolation with limited influence on decision-making.

  • Paul Wood – Group Leader
  • Ashley Baxter
  • Bob Broughton
  • Helen Powell
  • Bob Sampson
  • Judy Stevens

South Kesteven Independents – 4 Members
At the time of the Tory coup, three sitting Conservatives were so outraged and disappointed that they resigned the whip and established their own group. They didn’t want to be part of the existing group of Independents possibly because having a separate group would give them more control over who should sit on committees. Having said that, they do work closely with the other independents, often comparing notes and sharing information,
Sadly, it is suspected that given the age and long-service of  each of the ‘SKindies’ it is unlikely that they will all stand again, let alone retain their seats, at next year’s elections.

  • Nick Craft – Group Leader
  • Mike Cook
  • Frank Turner
  • Felicity Cunningham

Independent (Unaligned) – 1 Member
Cllr Ian Selby has been a Councillor for an uninterrupted 20 years which makeslifeofbrian-hoodie him ‘Father of the Council’. Originally a Labour Councillor, he left after a fall-out within the group, won back his seat, but hasn’t yet succombed to the overtures of any of the other independent group making him the SKDC equivalent of the ‘Judean Peoples Front’.

Last year I nominated Cllr Selby as Leader of the Council in order that Cllr Matthew Lee would have to face an election to the post rather than enjoy a ‘coronation’. The vote was split 31-13 (I think) with several Tories abstaining revealing the ongoing civil war within their group.

Labour – 3 Members
In 2015 Labour had their worst SKDC election result for many years with only three Councillors successfully elected. Nevertheless, they have a Leader and a Deputy to maintain order among the rank and file (or Tracey as she is better known)!

Hopefully, next year some of the 200,000 recent converts to the Labour party might choose to mix things up a bit and fight for winnable seats in Grantham, Stamford and Bourne.

  • ‘Fair Deal’ Phil Dilks – Group Leader
  • Tracey Forman
  • Charmaine Morgan

Conservatives- 42 Members
There are loads of them. They are factions and pressure groups within the Grantham and Stamford Tory Party but mostly they present a united front even though one can often hear mutters of dissension in the Members’ tea room.

Lib-Dems – 0 Councillors.
There used to be some at SKDC but Nick Clegg did for them when he sold our nation’s students down the river.

Stamford Group of Independents – 0 Councillors.
Stamford has a strong independent group on its Town Council, some of whom were incumbent District Councillors until 2015. At the 2015 elections the group put up a full slate of 8 candidates across the 4 Stamford wards. Unfortunately, all of them were beaten by the Conservatives. Hopefully, next year, they will be more organised.

United Kingdom Independence Party – 0 Councillors.
In 2015, Felicity Cunningham was the only UKIP candidate elected to SKDC. Her party membership lapsed in Spring 2017 when she decided to join the newly formed SK Independents Group. Despite jumping ship, I suspect she will be the last SKDC UKIP Councillor in history.

If you would like to know more about the personalities, Parties, procedures and politics at SKDC I would be happy to hear from you. If you would like to join in yourself, even better!

March 2018 – Report to Market Deeping Town Council

School Solar Panels
The Fens Wind-power Co-operative which owned two of the turbines at Deeping St Nicholas is being wound up and is making a significant donation to environmental the local community. 57k has been allocated to install solar panels at local schools. I am pleased to report that, thanks to my intervention, two of Market Deeping’s schools are likely to benefit from the scheme. Furthermore, a fuel poverty advice programme which is planned for South Holland should also be available to Deepings residents. I am awaiting further details of how this will operate.

wind girls

Environment Overview and Scrutiny Group – 20rd February 2018
A dull meeting with the supposed aim of scrutinising the Council’s performance on a range of environmental issues including air quality, litter and trade waste. The Tories, as usual, asked almost no questions during the meeting. Cllr Craft (Ind, ex-Tory) and I asked quite a few questions.

Secret Street Lighting Workshop – 20th February 2018
A meeting took place, behind closed doors, to consider various options for reducing energy used by streetlighting including the option of switching them off. I am not permitted to say exactly what was discussed during the workshop but I can tell you: a) personally I have argued, at every opportunity, against turning off SKDC streetlights; and b) the principal outcome of the workshop was to agree to hold another secret workshop on 27th March.

SKDC Full Council (Budget) Meeting – 1st March 2018
Only 30 out of 56 Councillors braved the snowy weather to attend the Council’s annual budget meeting.

Last year, the Council agreed its annual budget unanimously although the subsequent leadership coup led to various significant amendments. This year’s budget was far more contentious with various balancing figures seemingly plucked from thin air. These include: a £30k reduction in consultancy costs to be achieved by consolidating the consultancy budgets from around the various council departments; £345k in unspecified reductions in corporate costs; £350k proposed expenditure on a ‘leisure and heritage strategy’.

There was a good deal of discontent with the proposed budget among some of the Tory ranks and also among the opposition. There were some ambitious ideas including an extension of the Big Clean project and an in-house enforcement team for enviro-crime (litter, graffiti etc) which I applauded but in order that the budget should not be passed through on the nod, I presented three costed amendments which would have reduced the overall budget requirement by £400k:
• A modest increase in car park charges in Stamford and Grantham (of less than 25% and less than 20p/hour). This would have raised revenue of £182k/annum. In contrast, the Tory budget suggests an increased revenue for car park charges of £250k/annum merely by stricter enforcement, new technology (with a significant capital cost for installation), better promotion and without increasing charges.
• Adjustments to the some of the figures, especially the more outlandish proposals (e.g. combining the new ‘innovation team’ (£97k) with the new ‘transformation team’ (£120k) and reducing the budget by 20%)
• Protecting the existing dedicated 50k reserve for Hardship and Welfare rather than allowing it to be absorbed into the general pot.

During the debate, some cabinet members tried to divert attention from the real arguments by falsely accusing me of breaches of protocol: firstly, the Leader, Cllr Matthew Lee (Con), protested that I was planning to raise 9 separate amendments (the paperwork in front of him showed clearly there were only 3); secondly, Cllr Lee suggested that I hadn’t liaised with council officers before presenting the amendments (I most certainly had liaised with officers); thirdly Cllr Adam Stokes (Con), Portfolio Holder for Finance, complained that I hadn’t shared my amendments prior to the meeting (I had e-mailed the most of the content to him a week before the meeting and received no response).

Unsurprisingly, my three amendments were defeated, however the nebulous and over-optimistic budget has at least been publicly challenged.

Cllr Morgan (Lab) also submitted an amendment to ask for a measly £1,000 contribution to the legal costs of the ongoing Grantham Hospital campaign. This debate prompted a succession of Tories to proclaim how much they supported this important campaign before they all voted against the amendment.

Later, the meeting agreed unanimously to make permanent the appointment of the hitherto interim Chief Executive, Aidan Rave. It also agreed to hold a consultation on the enlargement of Corby Glen Parish Council from 7 to 9 Councillors.

I travelled to and from the meeting, as I often do, with Cllr Judy Stevens of DSJ. There are obvious advantages to lift-sharing not least reducing the cost of mileage claims to the Council Tax payers. The journey home took over two hours due to the inclement weather and included over thirty minutes stationary in the snow on the A1. North Kesteven DC was due to hold its equivalent budget meeting on the same day but decided to postpone due to the inclement weather. Unfortunately, the South Kesteven constitution does not allow Full Council meetings to be postponed.

Development Management Meeting – 6th March 2018
A relatively short (almost 2.5 hours) but interesting meeting of the planning committee discussed three planning applications.

The first was a sub-terranean eco-build in Castle Bytham. This had the support of the Parish Council but planning officers recommended refusal because the project would an ‘isolated home in the countryside’ and was not ‘innovative’. I am pleased to report that Councillors agreed the site was not ‘isolated’ (it is barely 50 yards from the parish hall!) and it is innovative. Consequently the Ctte voted contrary to officers’ recommendations and approved the dwelling.

The second application was for a new storey school building in the environs of St Wulfram’s Church in Grantham. This was passed by 8 votes to 6 proving again that every individual vote makes a difference.

The third application concerned a Section 106 agreement where, several years ago, a developer had agreed to contribute £127k to the costs of improving a junction with the A1. The developer argued that this work was no longer necessary and therefore the money was not required. The application was deferred to allow for further consultation with LCC Highways to take place.

Friends of Mill Field – Update
The campaign to register Mill Field as a Village Green continues. A dedicated webpage will soon be established to enable supporters to donate towards the ongoing legal costs.
Some of the group were also planning to meet Cllr Mike King (Con), SKDC Portfolio holder for Planning. This meeting was postponed due to the inclement weather.

Persimmon Estate
Despite a regular exchange of e-mails with the enforcement team at SKDC, no enforcement action has yet been taken in relation to the litany of unfinished works at the ‘Brambles’ estate behind Tesco. These include:
• Repairs to road surface on Godsey Lane
• Bringing Charter Avenue and other roads to an adoptable standard
• Non-compliant, even dangerous, footpath to the rear of Tesco
• Focal point and public open space
• Allotments to be handed over to Town Council

With regard to the allotments, I would suggest they are not fit for purpose. The allotments site is not secure leaving it vulnerable to vandalism, theft and other pests. Furthermore, the area has more tarmac than soil. A very disappointing response to a very well-intentioned idea. Incidentally, the Town Council has a duty under the Small Holdings and Allotments Act 1908 (c.36) to provide allotments if residents want them.

Market Deeping Town Centre
The Co-op store is due to close on 17th March, 2018. The premises will be occupied by Poundstretcher although I do not know exactly when.

New River Retail have assured me there are no plans to close the petrol filling station.

I had a meeting with an SKDC officer and Councillor Moran regarding SKDC aspirations for a Saturday market. It seems likely that businesses and other stakeholders will soon be consulted on proposals.

Auger car park

Here is an excerpt from SKDC Cabinet minutes from January 2005 when the Tories decided to sell off the council car park next to the Co-op store in Market Deeping Town Centre.

Forthcoming Events
West Deeping Village Hall is hosting a live theatre performance of “We are the Lions, Mr Manager” on Saturday 24th March.

That’s all for this report. As ever, if you need any further information please get in touch.

Cllr Ashley Baxter
Independent District Councillor
for Market and West Deeping
07799 077090
a.baxter@southkesteven.gov.uk